With a
beaming smile and white feather clips in her hair, this is the loveable
Down's syndrome girl whose photo Russian parents campaigned to have
removed from their kids' school yearbook.
Marsha Koltysheva, seven, was included in a class photograph and they didn't want her seen next to their children.
Some
parents at Moscow School Number 1392 returned the yearbook which
included the picture of Masha, who is the daughter of class teacher,
Marina
Koltysheva.
Class photo: Seven-year-old Down's
syndrome girl Masha Koltysheva (pictured with her mother Marina, the
class teacher) prompted outrage from parents when a photo of her
appeared in school yearbook in Russia
Controversy: Masha's mother Marina
Koltysheva is the class teacher at Moscow School Number 1392. Masha was
unwell on the day the photos were taken and she brought Masha into
school
'Disruptive': But some parents
complained that Masha (pictured with her mother Marina) is disruptive in
class and were angry a picture of her appeared in the school yearbook
alongside their children
Mrs
Koltysheva brought her to school to sit in her class of 11 and
12-year-olds because her nanny was ill, and she had no-one to look after
the child.
But
some of the class complained to their parents, who demanded the teacher
should be fired, claiming that Masha was disruptive.
One female pupil is known to have told her parents: 'It's not normal that she is in our classroom.'
Many others in the class were happy playing with a girl they say as 'affectionate' and 'quiet' and 'not at all disruptive'.
However,
a mother Anastasiya Artemova, whose daughter Polina is in Mrs
Koltysheva's class, complained: 'Masha started behaving like a hooligan
in the classroom.
'She
began to hurt some of the girls. Polina came back home and complained
that Masha was pulling her hair and pushing her hard in the canteen.
'I
went to see the director and asked him to sort out this matter and to
explain why our children are studying with a child aged 7, why she is in
the classroom when she is the daughter of our teacher.'
Some parents demanded the teacher should be fired, it was reported.
Anger: Some of the parents have called
for Mrs Koltysheva (right) to be sacked after she brought Masha (left),
seven, to her class of 11 to 12-year-olds
Fight: Masha's
mother hit back at the criticism by saying her daughter loved being
around people, enjoyed going to school and has never 'hit or kicked
anybody'
Vladimir
Chanturiya, father of another classmate, said: 'She came to our school
with her child. This is a child with special needs, but in my opinion
she was doing fine in this group of children.
'Children
are cruel by their nature, they are not ready to cooperate with
children who have special needs and special characters.
'But
this is not the problem of the children, it is the problem of the
parents. They have to bring them up with tolerant attitude.'
Olga
Sinyaeva, whose daughter Asya Aslan is also in the same class, agreed:
'Some children are against Masha's presence in the classroom.
'Of course, they say something. But it is not their language, they repeat the intonations of their parents.
'Masha once just hugged me and started kissing me.
'Of course, I didn't push her away but hugged her too, and this is how we spent some minutes.
'But other mothers were standing around us, and it was as silent as in a coffin.
Cruel: A mother whose daughter was in
Mrs Koltysheva's class said Masha (pictured) behaved like a 'hooligan in
the classroom', pulled her daughter's hair and pushed her in the
canteen
Hurt: Masha's mother (pictured) said
she may have to resign from her teaching job at the school to devote her
time to solely looking after her daughter
'When Masha finished hugging me, I looked up at them and saw that they just did not understand what was going on.'
On
the day Masha came into the school a photographer was there to take
photographs for the yearbook and Mrs Koltysheva thought it would be a
good opportunity to get a professional picture of her daughter.
She asked the photographer to take a picture of Masha but he mistakenly included it in the class yearbook page.
Hitting
back the criticism, Masha's mother told of how the young girl loved
being around people, enjoyed going to school and has never 'hit or
kicked anybody'.
She said: 'People keep saying, "unusual, special child", but for me she is very much a normal child.
'She
likes it when she is not alone but interacting with people. When there
is no such opportunity, she takes her big Lilly doll and plays with
her.'
Loving: Her mother said of Masha (pictured): 'She likes it when she is not alone but interacting with people'
Schoolmates:
Olga Sinyaeva (right), whose daughter Asya Aslan (left) is also in the
same class, agreed: 'Some children are against Masha's presence in the
classroom'
The teacher, with 25 years' experience, went on: 'I think I will have to resign and to focus fully on my child.
'There are ways to survive, and I must survive.'
She denied doing anything improper in having Masha in her class.
'The school director visited our lessons and was present during a lesson, and Masha was there.
'The situation was known and clear. My child did not disturb anybody, she sat at the back desk with a boy.
'I
think the girls just got interested in Masha. Maybe she pushed them
once in the break and they laughed, and Masha got excited. She feels
good when others are happy.'
School
director Denis Bakharev, claimed the scandal is exaggerated, claiming
his school is part of a system of inclusive education where the children
with special needs can study.
Campaigner: The parents' angry
reaction led to supermodel Natalia Vodianova (pictured), who has an
autistic sister, to launch an #OurMasha campaign in support
'There
was no negative attitude to Marina's child,' he said, despite parents
admitting anonymously that they had asked for the teacher to be fired.
'There is no such attitude now, either from the children, nor the parents, and certainly not from the school administration.
'She is a good teacher, with perfect qualifications and long experience in schools.'
Masha's case led supermodel Natalia Vodianova - who has an autistic sister - to launch a #OurMasha campaign in support.
The
model, 33, said: 'Here is a person in a difficult situation who is
denied support and the most basic thing - human understanding.'
She runs the Naked Heart Foundation, which supports children with disabilities, and is known for speaking out against injustice.
0 comments:
Post a Comment